A factory scorecard turns a feeling about a supplier into a number. You score each candidate from 1 to 5 on ten criteria, multiply by a weight and add up. The best candidate is the one with the highest total, and you can see why.
Last updated: October 28, 2026. Written by the Cherrysmock team from real wholesale orders of hand-smocked kids clothing made in Hanoi, Vietnam.
Quick answer: List ten criteria, give each a weight that adds up to 100 percent, score each supplier from 1 to 5 after you have seen samples, and calculate the weighted total. A supplier above about 4.0 is a strong candidate; below 3.0 needs a strong reason.
Buying wholesale for your boutique?
Cherrysmock is a hand-smocked children's clothing manufacturer in Hanoi. Browse wholesale smocked clothing, princess dresses wholesale (ready to ship), seasonal smocked collections or design your own smocked clothing. MOQ from 10 pcs per style.
Get the price list on WhatsAppThe thresholds are our working guide. The weights below suit small hand-smocked orders; change them for your own priorities.

The ten factory scorecard criteria and weights
| # | Criterion | Weight | How to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hand smocking and embroidery skill | 15% | Close-up photos, video, sample |
| 2 | MOQ flexibility under 50 pieces | 15% | Written MOQ per design |
| 3 | Lead time | 10% | Dated production plan |
| 4 | Sample quality | 15% | Run the smocking quality check |
| 5 | Safety and documents | 10% | Test reports for your market |
| 6 | Communication | 5% | Reply time and clarity |
| 7 | Price and landed cost | 10% | Full quote with freight |
| 8 | Private label | 5% | Woven labels, tags, packaging |
| 9 | Custom design and mock-up | 10% | Free 2D mock-up |
| 10 | Stability and references | 5% | Two customer references |
A worked factory scorecard for three suppliers
| Criterion (weight) | Supplier A | Supplier B | Supplier C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smocking skill (15%) | 5 | 3 | 4 |
| MOQ (15%) | 4 | 5 | 3 |
| Lead time (10%) | 4 | 3 | 5 |
| Sample quality (15%) | 5 | 3 | 4 |
| Safety documents (10%) | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| Communication (5%) | 4 | 4 | 3 |
| Price (10%) | 3 | 5 | 3 |
| Private label (5%) | 4 | 3 | 5 |
| Custom design (10%) | 5 | 3 | 4 |
| Stability (5%) | 4 | 3 | 5 |
| Weighted total | 4.20 | 3.65 | 4.00 |
Supplier A: 0.15 x 5 + 0.15 x 4 + 0.10 x 4 + 0.15 x 5 + 0.10 x 3 + 0.05 x 4 + 0.10 x 3 + 0.05 x 4 + 0.10 x 5 + 0.05 x 4 = 4.20. The names and scores are illustrative.
Use the free factory scorecard Excel sheet
The worksheet download includes a factory scorecard sheet: enter scores from 1 to 5 and it calculates the weighted total and the rank, using named weights so you can change them in one place.
Fill in the factory scorecard after the sample, not before
A supplier who gives a good first impression can disappoint on the sample. Score communication and price first, then update the other lines after you hold the sample. Do not give a 5 for something you have not seen.

Adjust factory scorecard weights to your priorities
| If you are… | Raise the weight of |
|---|---|
| Launching private label | Private label, custom design |
| Selling to a high-end market | Sample quality, smocking skill |
| Short on cash | MOQ, price |
| Selling seasonal items | Lead time |
What to do with the result
Place a trial order with the top two, not only the winner. See how to find and negotiate small MOQ and questions before you pay a deposit. After the first order, update the scores with what actually happened.
Mistakes to avoid
- Scoring everything 4 or 5 to avoid decisions.
- Changing weights after you see the scores.
- Using the factory scorecard once and never updating it.
Keep a score history
Save each version of the scorecard with the date. A supplier that scored 3.6 in March and 4.2 in September is improving, and one that fell from 4.2 to 3.4 needs a conversation. A factory scorecard is a living document; use it at every reorder.
Share the factory scorecard with your team
If a partner or buyer helps you choose suppliers, ask each person to fill in the factory scorecard separately, then compare. Large gaps show where you disagree about priorities. A factory scorecard also gives you a record to show a bank or investor that supplier choice was based on evidence.

Factory scorecard template
A factory scorecard turns your experience with a supplier into numbers you can compare each season.
| Measure | How to score | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| On-time delivery | Delivered on agreed date = 5; each week late โ1 | 30% |
| Quality | Fail rate under 2% = 5; over 8% = 1 | 30% |
| Communication | Replies within one working day = 5 | 15% |
| Sample accuracy | Bulk matches sample = 5 | 15% |
| Claims handling | Fair and fast = 5 | 10% |
Using the factory scorecard
Score after each order and share the result with the supplier. A total under 3.5 out of 5 means agree an improvement plan; two seasons under 3 means look for an alternative.
Factory scorecard: key points
- A factory scorecard rates delivery, quality and communication.
- Weight delivery and quality highest in a factory scorecard.
- Update the factory scorecard after every order.
- Share factory scorecard results with the supplier.
- Use the factory scorecard to compare suppliers.
FAQ
What is a factory scorecard?
A table that scores suppliers on weighted criteria so you can compare them using numbers.
What criteria should a factory scorecard include?
Craft skill, MOQ, lead time, sample quality, safety documents, communication, price, private label, custom design and references.
How do I choose weights?
Give more weight to what matters most for your shop, and make the weights add up to 100 percent. Change them before you score, not after.
Is there a template?
Yes. The Cherrysmock boutique worksheets include a supplier scoring sheet with a weighted total and ranking.
Put Cherrysmock on your scorecard
Ask for a sample, close-up photos and a quote on WhatsApp, then score us against your other suppliers.
Message Cherrysmock on WhatsApp with the styles you are considering, or run your numbers first in the free Cherrysmock Planner, which calculates cost price, selling price, stock and cash for your shop.
Found this useful? Send it to a boutique owner who would use it too.
Keep reading
More guides for boutique owners, picked for you.
Ready-to-ship styles for your boutique
Low MOQ from 10 pcs per style. Ready to ship in 5-7 days.
Tell us your budget and customers. We reply within one business day.
WhatsApp usHow to order








